Blog Post

FCA research: Consumers ‘not always aware of consequences’ of execution-only mortgage purchases

Ian Holmes • May 28, 2019

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has published research which shows consumers do not always understand the protections they are losing when they complete mortgages by execution-only.

The research found that execution-only customers generally understood they were selecting their mortgage without receiving advice.

However, it also revealed that customers who went down either application route – execution-only or advised – struggled to understand the disclosure documents that were tested.

“This meant they were not always aware of the consequences of a decision to make an execution-only application, including what protections they would miss out on or what rights they would retain by choosing not to receive regulated advice,” the FCA noted.


Excluded customer understanding of protections lost

The regulator conducted the research as part of its consultation to open-up the advice rules to allow more execution-only cases to be completed.

While it referenced the research within the consultation paper, it did not give a full explanation of its findings, excluding the point that consumers did not realise the protections they were losing.

In CP17/19 the regulator said: “In general, consumers did understand that they were buying without advice. However, sometimes consumers thought they were giving up more regulatory protections than they were.

“We hope that firms will find the insights from this research useful in thinking about the way in which they disclose the implications of buying on an execution-only basis.”

It also did not list the risk of consumers potentially giving up protections without realising it in its cost benefit analysis.

Mortgage Solutions has contacted the FCA several times asking for more details about the research, and to follow-up its consultation paper, however it has not yet responded.


Customers don’t understand protections

The research publication, Buying a mortgage without advice: How we might help customers understand execution-only disclosures , highlighted five key issues around the presentation of the disclosure documents and suggested ways in which they could be improved.

The five problems identified related to the process, content and design of the disclosure document being introduced to customers.

They were:

  • The disclosure document ‘gets lost’ among other documents.
  • Customers don’t understand what protections they have.
  • Customers can struggle to understand the disclosure document as it often requires them to interpret technical language.
  • Customers miss or skim over essential information because the design makes the document unappealing or hard to navigate.
  • The disclosure document does not feel important.

A series of potential changes to improve the disclosure document were noted within the research paper which was produced by Revealing Reality.

Mortgage Solutions has also asked the FCA if it plans to implement or recommend that these changes are made to tackle the concerns raised.

The FCA has not yet responded to this enquiry.


Heavily criticised

The regulator’s consultation to encourage execution-only purchases has been heavily criticised by the mortgage advice industry.

Association of Mortgage Intermediaries (AMI) chief executive Robert Sinclair said it was a “deceitful document” and that rowing back on the Mortgage Market Review was “dangerous”.

In a contribution for Mortgage Solutions , advice firm and network JLM added that the changes were in danger of leaving consumers “seriously exposed”.

However lender trade body UK Finance welcomed the move while online aggregator Compare the Market said consumers should not be pushed into paying for advice if they did not want it.


08 Dec, 2022
We try to give you the facts
by Ian Holmes 21 Oct, 2022
The increase in equity release pricing is raising concern with rolling-up debt hitting the property value faster
by Ian Holmes 15 Oct, 2022
Landlords could face bills of up to £10,000 per property under new EPC proposals
27 Jun, 2022
How will the change affect you?
04 Aug, 2021
but still remains in double digits
04 Aug, 2021
What is Tenants in Common?
by Ian Holmes 02 Apr, 2020
The Financial Conduct Authority has today (02/04/2020) proposed a range of new measures to support households facing sudden financial hardship as result of the coronavirus, including three-month payment freezes on loans and credit card debt. The package, intended to complement relief already announced by government to support mortgage holders, furloughed staff, renters and the self-employed, also includes pledges to slash interest rates on arranged overdrafts up to 500 pounds to zero, for up to three months. The FCA, which supervises banks and credit providers across Britain also said consumers using any of these temporary measures should not see their credit rating affected. It also said it would ensure all overdraft customers were no worse off on price when compared to prices they were charged before recent overdraft changes came into force.
by Ian Holmes 24 Mar, 2020
Nationwide Building Society has brought back its two-year residential tracker mortgages just days after the product was withdrawn from its offering. The mortgages will go live on 25 March, with house purchase and first-time buyer products starting from a rate of 1.39 per cent and remortgages from 1.19 per cent. The products will cover a range of loan to value tiers and come with both £0 and £999 fee options. Henry Jordan, director of mortgages at Nationwide, said the society took the “prudent decision” to consider the impact of the two interest rate cuts on its range. “We are re-introducing two-year trackers to our mortgage range to enable us to offer products with flexibility and no early repayment charges,” he said. Rate reduction Nationwide has also announced it will pass on a further 0.15 per cent rate reduction to existing variable rate borrowers to reflect the cuts made to the Bank of England bank rate. This follows on from the society confirming it would pass on the initial 0.50 per cent reduction to borrowers from 1 April. With the bank rate now at a record low of 0.10 per cent, Nationwide’s base mortgage rate (BMR) and standard mortgage rate (SMR) will reduce by an additional 0.15 per cent to 2.10 per cent and 3.59 per cent respectively, with these new rates coming into effect on 15 April. Borrowers on an existing tracker rate mortgage will also see their rates reduce by a further 0.15 per cent. Jordan added: “With a second cut in interest rates in just over a week, it is important that borrowers have clarity about what this second change means for them and the future interest and payments on their mortgages. “By passing on this latest rate reduction in full, from 15 April, we hope to minimise mortgage costs for our members during this difficult period.” Earlier, the society closed its dedicated broker support line as a result of government advice surrounding coronavirus. Jordan added: “While we continue to work hard with valuation and conveyancing partners to progress applications, we ask members and brokers to bear with us during what is an unprecedented period.”
by Ian Holmes 18 Mar, 2020
Following chancellor Rishi Sunak’s announcement that mortgage lenders would offer a three month holiday on repayments, the bank has confirmed it will offer other rescue measures, as well at the 90 day break, depending on the borrowers’ needs. The bank said it would consider switching borrowers from capital repayment to interest-only for up to 12 months. Further measures to help borrowers include an extension of the mortgage term to lower payments, and the availability of short and long term repayment plans for missed mortgage payments. Borrowers who think they will face financial difficulty are being told to contact the bank to speak to one of its specialist support teams to discuss their options. A Barclays spokesperson said: “As a responsible lender, it is crucial that we offer the right support to our customers at this time. “We have therefore decided to offer customers who are potentially facing financial difficulty, a number of options to support them through this time.” Before the chancellor’s address to the nation yesterday evening, Mortgage Solutions reported Lloyds Banking Group had pledged not to charge borrowers fees on missed mortgage payments. That bank, along with NatWest, Nationwide and Barclays, have all confirmed taking a payment holiday will not leave a black mark on borrowers’ credit profiles.
by Ian Holmes 25 Feb, 2020
This was below than 2018’s annual increase of 3.3 per cent, and weaker than the 2.6 per cent growth seen in 2013. All regions saw a drop in growth; England’s prices increased one per cent compared to 2018’s three per cent and prices in Scotland grew 1.8 per cent compared to 4.6 per cent the year before. In Wales, a four per cent growth was seen, down from 2018’s 4.8 per cent and Northern Ireland saw house prices rise by 3.5 per cent. This was a slowdown from the region’s 4.6 per cent rise in 2018. Local changes Locally, the strongest growth was seen in North Devon, where the average price of a house rose 8.9 per cent to £247,590. Three of the top five local areas to see strong growth were in Wales. Land Registry attributed this to the removal of the Severn Bridge tolls making it more affordable for those who work in Bristol to live on the Welsh side of the River Severn. The biggest falls occurred in Kensington and Chelsea, where the average house price dropped 7.7 per cent to £1,256,713. Four of the five local areas which saw the weakest growth were in London and the South East. Land Registry said this followed a “general slowdown” in the London property market since mid-2016 and was probably due to the area being “disproportionately affected by regulatory and tax changes”.
Show More
Share by: